Stauffer's Star Cookies | Classic Animal Crackers in Star Shapes
We've taken our classic animal cracker recipe—the one families have loved since 1871—and shaped it into delightful stars. Stauffer's Star Cookies deliver that same lightly sweet, satisfying crunch you remember, now in a shape that's perfect for little hands, lunch boxes, and everyday snacking.
Our star cookies are baked with simple ingredients and no artificial flavors, keeping the authentic taste that's made Stauffer's a trusted name for generations. Each crispy star offers the wholesome goodness you expect from our bakery, whether you're enjoying them straight from the bag, dunking them in milk, or packing them for on-the-go adventures.
What makes our star cookies special
Simple Ingredients, Timeless Taste
We bake Stauffer’s Star Cookies with enriched wheat flour, sugar, vegetable oil, and just a hint of vanilla—ingredients you can recognize and pronounce. Our recipe stays true to the original animal cracker formula that’s been delighting families for over 150 years, with no high-fructose corn syrup or artificial additives.
The light sweetness comes from real sugar, balanced perfectly so each star cookie tastes wholesome rather than overly sugary. We believe the best snacks are the ones that don’t compromise on quality, which is why we source our ingredients carefully and bake every batch with the same attention to detail our founders valued in 1871. The result is a cookie that tastes like childhood memories—simple, pure, and genuinely satisfying.
Perfect for Every Snacking Occasion
Lunchbox Ready
Our star-shaped cookies fit perfectly into sandwich bags and small containers, making them an ideal addition to school lunches and daycare snacks. The resealable bag keeps the remaining cookies fresh and crispy, so you can pack just the right portion without worrying about waste or staleness.
Travel-Friendly Snacking
Stauffer’s Star Cookies travel exceptionally well—they’re sturdy enough to survive backpacks, purses, and car consoles without crumbling into dust. We’ve packed them for road trips, airplane rides, hiking adventures, and office breaks. The mess-free nature and individually portionable format make these stars a favorite among parents and busy professionals alike.
The Stauffer's Star Cookie Difference
While many companies have tried to replicate the animal cracker experience, we’ve been perfecting our recipe since before the industrial revolution. Our bakery expertise means we understand exactly how long to bake each batch for that signature snap, how to balance the dough for consistent texture, and how to keep the flavor profile clean and approachable.
The star shape isn’t just about aesthetics—it’s about creating the perfect surface-area-to-thickness ratio for optimal crispness. Each point of the star bakes to a golden finish, while the center remains sturdy enough to hold up to dipping. We’ve tested countless variations to ensure every Stauffer’s star cookie delivers the same satisfying crunch from first bite to last.
More Classic Stauffer's Cookies & Crackers
Rated 4.8 by verified buyers
Questions About Stauffer's Star Cookies
Yes, our star cookies use the exact same classic recipe as our original animal crackers that we've been baking since 1871. The only difference is the shape—we've formed our time-tested dough into stars instead of animals. You'll get the same lightly sweet taste, crispy texture, and wholesome ingredients you expect from all Stauffer's products.
Many families enjoy having both varieties on hand for different occasions, since the star shape appeals to some children more than others, but rest assured the flavor profile is identical.
The number of Stauffer's Star Cookies per bag varies depending on the package size you purchase, but our standard family-size bags typically contain approximately 80-100 individual star cookies. Because we bake by weight rather than count, and natural variations in dough can slightly affect size, the exact number may vary by a few cookies from bag to bag.
Each serving size is clearly marked on the nutrition panel to help you portion appropriately for your family's needs.
Stauffer's Star Cookies do not contain nuts or peanuts as ingredients in the recipe. However, they are produced in a facility that also processes products containing tree nuts and peanuts, so there is a possibility of cross-contact.
If you or someone in your household has a severe nut allergy, we recommend reviewing the allergen statement on your specific package and consulting with your healthcare provider. We take allergen control seriously but cannot guarantee a completely nut-free environment in our shared production facilities.
Absolutely! Many customers use our star cookies as a base for creative snack activities. Children enjoy decorating them with frosting, using them to make edible star garland, or crushing them for pie crusts and cheesecake toppings.
The sturdy texture holds up well to light frosting application, and the flat surface provides a nice canvas for simple decorating projects. Some families also use them as cake toppers, ice cream accompaniments, or crushed as a coating for chocolate-dipped fruit. The possibilities are limited only by your imagination.
You can find Stauffer's Star Cookies in the cookie and cracker aisle of most major grocery stores, supermarkets, and mass retailers across the United States. We're available at chains like Walmart, Target, Kroger, Safeway, and many regional grocers.
If your local store doesn't currently stock our star cookies, ask the store manager to add them to their inventory—retailers often respond to customer requests. You can also purchase directly from our website or through select online retailers for convenient home delivery.
When stored properly in the resealable bag in a cool, dry location, our star cookies will maintain their crispy texture and fresh taste for several weeks after opening. We recommend consuming within 30 days of opening for optimal freshness and crunch.
The key is keeping moisture out—always press the air out and seal the bag tightly after each use. If your cookies do soften slightly due to humidity, you can restore some crispness by placing them on a baking sheet in a 200°F oven for 3-5 minutes.
Stauffer's Star Cookies are a popular choice for toddlers and young children because of their manageable size, simple ingredients, and pleasant texture that dissolves relatively easily when chewed. The star shape is easy for small hands to grip, and the light sweetness appeals to young palates.
That said, all hard or crunchy foods pose a potential choking risk for children under four years old. We recommend adult supervision during snack time, ensuring children are seated while eating, and following your pediatrician's guidance regarding age-appropriate foods for your specific child.